We spent one night here before leaving the island, after staying at other hotels in Rodney Bay. The headline: Avoid!
There were a few positives: the ferry ride was quick and hassle-free, and the hotel check-in staff were accommodating.
However, our experience at Doolittles restaurant was disappointing. It took them 40 minutes to bring us two coffees and 90 minutes for two small, overpriced breakfasts, even though there were only a few other people in the restaurant. The staff seemed uninterested and overall, it was a very poor experience.
Instead, we recommend walking to The Villa restaurant, which is approximately a 10-minute walk away. They have a 5-star hotel restaurant with attentive staff, and the prices are even lower than at Doolittles!
The rooms were clean, but they looked old and in need of renovation. Even with all the lights on during the day, it was still quite dark. However, the management seemed to have made some improvements, as the air conditioning worked well and the shower had hot water and good pressure.
The pool was more like a small pond (it would be funny if it weren't so sad), and the beach was tiny, with only around 8 worn-out sun chairs.
If you're reading this, please save your money and stay somewhere else - you'll be glad you did! Margiot Bay may have been lovely in the 80s, but it's not a good representation of it now.
It's worth mentioning that the owner of Margiot Beach Club - Dive Resort has a concerning habit of publicly posting people's passport numbers in response to negative TripAdvisor reviews. Let's hope I don't become the next victim of this.