Shelter Island - all beaches

The parking is convenient and the bathrooms are well-maintained. The only drawback is that the water is shallow and filled with sharp rocks, so it's necessary to wear water shoes to avoid getting injured.

This shoreline boasts unparalleled beauty, yet regrettably, it is exclusive to local residents. I had eagerly made the journey from my home in Queens to bask in the seaside scenery, only to be halted by a police vehicle patrolling the parking lot, scrutinizing non-resident vehicles. The area is clearly under surveillance, and I cannot fathom why such a magnificent beach would be restricted to a select few. How I wish I had known of this limitation prior to embarking on my journey. Save yourself the trouble and seek out a beach more accessible to all.

Today was not a pleasant experience. The beach was littered with garbage, there were too many cars parked on the road, and there were rude people around. To top it off, kids threw a ball at my car and hit the back window. It was a terrible experience at my local beach, which was overcrowded and dirty. Unfortunately, I will not be returning.

Upon arriving at Shelter Island, I was unfortunately stopped by the police who were checking vehicles. While I waited for my little errand to be completed, I decided to take a stroll along the beach. Despite the beautiful scenery and peaceful atmosphere, my experience was soured by receiving a $100 ticket. It's disheartening to see how the natural beauty of the beaches are being exploited for monetary gain. Perhaps implementing a payment system for visitors would be a fair compromise, but it seems as though the authorities are not concerned with the well-being of their guests.

This secluded paradise is a true treasure. I relish my solitary moments here, lost in thought and contemplation, or bask in the company of my loved ones while we revel in the breathtaking vistas.

This serene beach boasts vigilant lifeguards and well-maintained restrooms in close proximity. However, the beach terrain is slightly uneven with scattered rocks, making it a tad challenging to walk barefoot. It's advisable to wear flip flops or water sandals to ensure a comfortable stroll along the shore.